So I've been home from the big show in Paducah for awhile, and have been re-evaluating what I've seen and where my quilts should be displayed in the future. As I walked through the show this time, instead of being overwhelmed by all the amazing work; I realized that my work no longer belonged there. Why? This is my same old song. I am troubled by the lack of good design in so many quilts at so many shows. Oh yes, there were some wonderful pieces in the AQS show, but there were some that were not. AQS has been very supportive of me and my work, so I'd like to make it clear that this is about my opinion on what I see in
all competitions, not just in Paducah.
What direction is the quilting world headed? I've been asking myself this for some time now, and my answer is: I don't understand where it's going and I don't want to follow along; I need to take my own path. It is important that my quilts are uncluttered in design with strong visual impact.
 |
A Brighter Day, by Ann Fahl, the most prize winning quilt I have ever made |
I love thread work, of all kinds, but quilter's have gotten all tied up with doing too much thread work and heavy heavy machine quilting--to the extreme! We have forgotten that the original design of the quilt is the most important element, the thread work in whatever form, just adds texture and surface interest. As we have gone overboard on the heavy quilting, so have the quilt judges. They are impressed by the quantity and quality of the thread work and they seem to have forgotten to consider the overall impact of the color and design of the quilt FIRST.
In my opinion, the overall design should be the first consideration when judging, then the workmanship should be considered next. In other words, only those quilts with good design should be selected from the category, then the workmanship should be evaluated to determine which ones are winners. It appears to me that the quilting/thread work is evaluated first and wins the judges consideration so the design qualities are overlooked. This would account for so many quilts with poor design winning at shows. Yes the quilting is totally amazing on so many of the quilts today, but it isn't the
only part of the art form. Great quilting cannot make a poorly designed and conceived quilt-- a good one!
Whether one makes traditional quilts or original designs,
quilting is a visual art form. We must step back from our work, and examine its visual impact. Does it have a focal point? Does something draw the viewer in? Is there balance in the composition? Is there contrast between the colors and elements of the design? Is there something that unifies the design (ties the quilt together,) such as repetition of shape or color?
What can you do to improve the visual impact of your work? Take photos of your work in progress or look at the quilt with binoculars backwards. Always use a design wall to design and view the progress of your composition. Read books on design or take a class. Look through books, magazines and websites and see what you like best, and what is most appealing to your eye. We need to take a step or two back from heavy quilting and spend more time on the initial design, this is what should "sell" your quilt to your viewer or a judge.
A prize winning or a successful quilt should have both
a well designed top and great quilting!
Amen.
Ann Fahl